Red Hair

I want to dye my hair red, but I can't decide which red. And people I know are just no help - they either say "whichever's fine" or "why would you want to be a ranga?" XD So I thought I'd see if you guys could help me instead!

This is me normally:


And I'm trying to decide between dying my hair Shirley Manson red:


Or Melisandre red:

I couldn't find any good pictures of her hair, but it's very red anyway, basically the same as her dress.

Oh wow, sorry about the enormous pictures! I have no idea how to make them little O_O

Which colour do you think would suit me better (if anyone even has a preference, anyway )?

My hair is red! Well, it's really faded now, it's like a weird peachy/caramelly/orangey colour

Awesome! I'm like insanely in love with red hair XD But every time I try to test-dye it, it never turns out right D: So I think I'm gonna have to go straight into it with a permanent dye and whatnot O_O lol

But what was your natural colour like, and how did it turn out after you dyed it?

I like the red so much more than the orange. It looks more natural and less distracting I really wanted to try going auburn (like Bonnie Wright) and I was thinking of doing it in college or something